The Dublin Murder Mysteries: Books four to six Read online

  Every base was covered.

  The driver, whose car Mackin had commandeered, was thanked for his contribution in helping to stop the gang and was promised a loan vehicle while a reputable garage repaired his car.

  ‘Have you seen it?’ Foley whispered to West when the man had walked away, shaking his head. ‘It’s totalled.’

  West hadn’t given it much attention. He did now and grimaced when he saw the damage. Foley was probably right, it looked beyond repair. Morrison would not be happy.

  He wasn’t going to sacrifice Mackin on that particular altar. It would be reported as being his idea. Thankfully, they’d caught the gang… well most of it, he amended. That would go a long way to appease the inspector.

  Foley stayed to monitor the various teams while Baxter headed off to St Columcille’s hospital to interview both victims and check up on Mackin.

  When he arrived back in the station two hours later, he had the younger man in tow.

  ‘I think they were glad to be rid of him,’ he told West and Andrews who were in conversation when he pushed through the door.

  Mackin grinned and said nothing.

  ‘Foley is just finishing up,’ Baxter said, ‘he’s hoping you’ll wait until he gets here before doing the interviews.’

  Andrews raised an eyebrow. ‘Wait?’

  Baxter blinked and looked from one to the other. He never could be sure when Andrews was taking the piss. ‘I just meant…’ he started.

  West took pity on him. ‘He’s pulling your leg, Seamus. Of course, we’re going to wait.’

  Baxter gave Andrews a thump on the arm. ‘You are such a bugger,’ he said.

  ‘You two can go ahead and start on one of the interviews,’ West said, ‘I’ll wait for Foley.’

  Mackin said nothing, but he had big brown eyes that did the talking for him and West wasn’t immune to their pleading. ‘We’ll need you a while longer, Garda Mackin,’ he said. ‘Write up your account of what happened while we’re waiting for Foley.’ He turned to walk to his office, stopped and looked back. ‘It might be better if you say that having the driver put his car across the exit was my idea. I think the car’s a write-off, Inspector Morrison might be a little annoyed.’

  ‘Annoyed,’ Andrews said, raising his eyes to heaven, ‘he’ll be steaming.’

  Mackin grinned and nodded. ‘Thank you, Sergeant.’

  ‘When Foley gets here, sit in the observation room. You can watch both interviews from there.’

  It was a quirk of the station. Because of lack of space, the two interview rooms were joined by one observation room. Sometimes, as now, it had its advantages. When he’d arrived in Foxrock, West had tried to get the team to call the rooms Interview One and Two, but had hit his head against a brick wall, and finally gave in. Within a few weeks he was calling them the Big One and the Other One just as the rest of the staff in the station did.

  Foley returned forty-five minutes later with reports that everything in Cornelscourt had returned to normal. He told a groaning West that the mechanics who’d arrived to tow away the Fiesta had laughed when he asked if repairs would be expensive. ‘They said it wouldn’t even fetch a few quid as scrap.’

  ‘We’d better get some results here, then, hadn’t we?’ West said.

  They headed into the Big One where one of the two men they’d arrested sat at the table, his solicitor sitting beside him, already looking bored.

  The formalities were quickly completed, and all four men sat back. West’s eyes flicked over the information on the A4 pad in front of him. Ciaran Maguire, twenty-five years old, with a string of convictions that ran into two pages.

  ‘You’ve excelled yourself this time,’ he said quietly. ‘Adding an accessory to attempted murder to your list.’

  Maguire’s upper lip rose in a sneer. ‘Don’t know what you’re talking about. We’ve never hurt no one.’ He shrugged a thin shoulder. ‘Well, apart from the odd dig when they weren’t co-operating.’

  ‘Both of the women you attacked today are going to require surgery,’ West said, his eyes hard. ‘That brings your charge up to grievous bodily harm which carries a mandatory minimum prison term. Your getaway driver deliberately drove at a member of the Garda Síochána. That’s attempted murder.’

  Maguire darted a look at his solicitor and licked his lips. ‘I wasn’t in the bloody car, was I?’

  West shrugged. ‘That’s why you’re being charged with being an accessory.’

  The solicitor, who obviously decided he’d better make some effort, asked, ‘Did the garda in question identify himself as such?’

  Maguire grinned.

  There was no point in lying, nor was there a need. ‘No,’ West admitted, ‘he didn’t.’

  ‘Ha!’ Maguire said, crossing his arms.

  ‘We’ll have the charges changed to an accessory to attempted murder of an innocent bystander then, shall we?’ West said, picking up his pen and scribbling some notes on the page in front of him.

  The solicitor checked his watch. ‘Let’s cut to the chase,’ he said, ‘you haven’t caught the driver, have you?’

  If he expected a response, he was quickly disappointed as West and Foley sat stony-faced.

  ‘I’ll take that as a no,’ he continued. ‘If my client can furnish you with details will that assist in reducing his sentence?’

  West stared across the table. It was what he wanted, in fact, what he’d expected. The solicitor knew that, but the game had to be played, and with his memory of Ken Blundell still fresh he wasn’t going to make an easy deal.

  ‘If your client furnishes us with information that enables us to catch the driver, we’ll be able to discuss terms.’

  The solicitor, Enda Careless, sighed. ‘I may be careless by name, Sergeant West, but not by nature. I’ll want much more than that, before I’ll advise my client to assist you.’

  ‘I’m not grassing to the pigs,’ Maguire growled.

  ‘Shut up,’ Careless said without looking at him. ‘If my client can furnish you with what you need, will you drop the accessory to attempted murder charge?’

  That was cutting straight to the point. West guessed the solicitor, on a fixed Legal Aid remuneration, wasn’t willing to waste more time than he needed. But he’d taken West by surprise. They both knew the charge of accessory to attempted murder was going to be a tough one to make stick. A good defence team could make the argument that Mackin had been partially responsible for putting himself in danger in the first place by blocking the exit.

  He opened his mouth to agree to drop this charge but closed it again and frowned. ‘I’ll have to discuss it with my superiors,’ he said.

  Careless, raising an eyebrow in surprise, shrugged and looked at his watch again. ‘Is this going to take long?’

  West shook his head, announced for the recording that he was stopping the interview and left the room. He could have made the decision. Damn it, he would have done a couple of months ago. But now, he was second-guessing his every move. He sighed, and a few minutes later tapped on Morrison’s door.

  ‘The solicitor is waiting for our response,’ he said, having given a brief but detailed summary of events.

  ‘Mackin wasn’t hurt?’ Morrison asked.

  ‘No, and anyway, to be honest, I’m not sure if the charge would stick. Mackin did well, but he put himself in a precarious position, and he didn’t identify himself as a garda.’ West frowned. ‘I was surprised Careless went for that. He could have asked for the grievous bodily harm charge to be dropped instead.’

  Morrison shook his head. ‘Don’t be fooled by his bored-looking persona act, Enda Careless is as sharp as a blade. He picked the one you’d be most likely to concede to, and,’ he added, ‘it’s probably the one that young thug is most afraid of.’

  West agreed. Despite Mackin’s air of bravado, there was a glimpse of fear when the charge had been mentioned. ‘So, we’ll accept his terms?’

  ‘Play a careful game, Sergeant,’ Morrison said, then he sm
iled briefly. ‘It’s one you’re good at.’ The smile was replaced by a sour grimace. ‘Can I assume the car is a write-off?’

  It was tempting to say he hadn’t heard. Easier, too. But honesty forced him to nod. ‘The mechanics who towed it away seem to think so. We’ve given the owner a replacement loan-car until we get something sorted.’

  The something would be expensive. Morrison’s grimace went from sour to curdled and he waved West away with a sharp, ‘You’d better get this third gang member, West, get him quickly and put this lot away so that, maybe, I can justify this expenditure to the powers that be.’

  ‘I’ll do my best, Inspector,’ West said turning to go, then remembering an old adage, leave on a positive note, he added, ‘Baxter and Foley did well today, and they had excellent assistance from Nick Mackin and Gemma Ryan.’

  Morrison nodded in acknowledgement but said nothing. He would, West knew, note the comment down as soon as he left the office. Smiling to himself, he called into the observation room to check on the other interview.

  ‘How’s it going in there?’ he asked Mackin who was sitting back, legs crossed as if he were at the cinema.

  ‘He’s made of tougher stuff than your’un,’ he said, nodding towards the man on the other side of the window. Oliver Fearon was a bigger, older man and, whereas Maguire’s criminal history was heavy on the robbery side, his was heavier on violence.

  West stood listening for a while. They’d made the right choice; this man was never going to give them anything.

  Back in the Big One, he sat and the recording was restarted. ‘Okay,’ he said, looking to the solicitor, ‘with your client’s history my superior isn’t too happy at cutting a deal.’ He waited a beat. ‘But I persuaded him it was in everyone’s best interest.’

  Enda Careless gave a knowing smile. ‘I thought you might,’ he murmured before turning to his client. ‘This is the best option for you. Tell them what they want to know. Don’t be stupid and fuck it up.’

  ‘You have one minute before I make the same offer to your friend next door,’ West said, crossing his arms.

  Maguire’s lip twisted. ‘Ollie’s never going to deal with you lot.’

  West shrugged. ‘It doesn’t really matter. We have both of you. We’ll just question your friends, your relatives and everyone and anyone you’ve spoken to in the last year. Uniformed gardaí will swarm your street, looking into every nook and cranny. I bet we’ll find plenty to interest us. Your friends will be so pleased.’

  Maguire paled. He could tell West wasn’t joking. Suddenly, taking the deal seemed like a good idea. They were going to find Connor Shields anyway.

  Five minutes later, West and Foley left the room together, and Maguire was taken away to a cell. Two hours later, Connor Shields was led in, growling abuse at the two gardaí who held him.

  By midnight, they had written confessions from Maguire and Shields, each man trying to offload as much blame as possible on the other. Ollie Fearon, on the other hand, refused to answer any questions, sitting silently sullen in the face of Andrews’ and Baxter’s best attempts.

  ‘We have him anyway,’ Andrews said later as they went over the statements given by the other two men. ‘They’ll all go down for a considerable amount of time for this. And your boy, Maguire, won’t do so well from your deal,’ he said with satisfaction, ‘both women said it was he, not Fearon, who threw the blows.’

  There was a message waiting for West on his desk. The garage had rung to confirm what he already knew. The car was a write-off.

  He threw the note toward Andrews who read it and shrugged. ‘It’s a banjaxed car, not a dead body. We were lucky there, Mike.’

  Lucky? West remembered feeling the blood drain from his face when he saw Mackin’s body lying on the road. Yes, they’d been damn lucky.

  10

  Next morning, West left Baxter and Foley to complete the paperwork on the Cornelscourt case while he went over the information he had on the child in the suitcase, looking for something he might have missed. There was nothing. Without identification, it would be impossible to trace her movements. Without a face it was virtually impossible to identify her.

  Stymied.

  He drummed his fingers on the desk. There must be something they could do. He’d no idea how much a facial reconstruction would cost; he’d no idea if they had the facilities to do it even if funds were available.

  He stopped drumming. There was someone who might know. He checked his contacts book and reached for the phone to dial the number. ‘May I speak to Dr Kennedy,’ he said when the phone was answered, ‘it’s Detective Sergeant West.’

  Put on hold, he held the phone away from his ear. There was only so much terrible music he was willing to listen to. He moved it closer again when the pathologist’s cheerful voice hailed him. ‘Mike, what can I do for you?’

  West smiled. He appreciated someone who didn’t waste time on pleasantries. ‘It’s about the child in the suitcase, Niall. We’re no nearer to finding out who she is. I was wondering about facial reconstruction. Do we have the facility?’

  ‘Not us, I’m afraid, but I know who does. The University of Dundee. They have a computer programme that can extrapolate facial features based on bone structure and nationality. It’s in the research phase as yet, but they’ve had some remarkable results.’

  ‘I wonder if they’d be interested in working on our girl then,’ West said, feeling the first stirrings of optimism he’d had with the case. ‘I don’t suppose you have a contact there, do you?’

  ‘No, I’m afraid not,’ the pathologist said regretfully, ‘but leave it with me and I’ll ask around. I’ll get back to you by late morning, if not before.’

  Settling for that, West thanked him, and hung up. ‘This might work,’ he muttered. With little enthusiasm, he switched on the computer and brought up the case audit he’d been trying to complete since the previous month. He was still chipping away at it when the phone rang an hour later. Picking it up in the expectation of hearing Niall Kennedy’s voice, he was surprised to hear a female voice instead.

  ‘It’s Fiona,’ she said, ‘Niall asked me to give you a buzz. You asked about the facial reconstruction work they’re doing in Dundee. I was at a conference there last year and went to a symposium on it.’

  ‘Do you know if they’ve done any work with children?’ he asked. ‘I’m afraid we’ve run into a brick wall trying to identify that child.’

  ‘They hadn’t a year ago, but I’ve no idea how advanced their research is at this stage.’ He heard a sigh, then the rustle of paper. ‘I have the contact details of one of the professors who spoke at the symposium. I’m afraid I can’t give it to you, but I could contact him, explain the situation and ask him to get in touch with you. Would that work?’

  ‘That would be great,’ he said. He wanted to add can you do it ASAP but didn’t. All he could do was hope she recognised the underlying urgency of his request.

  She must have done. ‘I’ll get right on it,’ she said, and before hanging up added, ‘you’ll owe me, of course.’

  He smiled briefly and put the phone down. He should continue the audit and get it finished, but there was only so much time he could spend on bureaucracy without going crazy. Luckily for him, Andrews appeared in the doorway with the offer of coffee. He’d not finished the last one, but it was cold so he nodded.

  Coffee in hand, he filled him in on the news. ‘Even if Fiona sends an email immediately,’ he said, ‘it’s unlikely we’ll hear back for several days.’

  But just as West finished his update, the phone rang.

  ‘Is that Garda West?’ the voice asked in a distinctive Scottish burr.

  ‘Yes, this is West.’ He raised an eyebrow at Andrews.

  ‘This is Professor Alistair McLeod,’ he said. ‘Fiona Wilson rang us about an interesting case you have there.’

  West, who’d expected her to email the man, was gratefully surprised she’d taken the trouble to ring. He definitely owed her.
<
br />   ‘Tell me about it,’ the professor said.

  Another man who didn’t bother with unnecessary pleasantries. Keeping to the bare facts, West filled him in. ‘We’re at a standstill, I’m afraid. Sickle-cell anaemia does indicate she may be of sub-Saharan origin, but that’s all we’ve got to go on.’

  ‘And you say she’s between two and three years of age?’

  ‘The pathologist based the estimate on her dentition.’

  The silence lasted so long that West wondered if he’d been cut off. ‘Hello?’

  ‘Oh, I’m still here. Just giving the situation some thought. We’ve not worked on someone so young. We’d have to shift some of the parameters.’

  West gave Andrews a thumbs-up. ‘But you’ll give it a go?’

  ‘Aye, we’ll give it a go. It will be interesting to see what we can achieve. But I’ll warn you, Garda West, at that age features are very poorly determined. It may not be of much help.’

  ‘But, then again, Professor McLeod, it may give us the break we need. Now,’ he said, wanting to get the process started as quickly as possible, ‘what do we need to do? And how much is this going to cost us?’

  A hearty chuckle came down the line. ‘Nay, it won’t cost you anything. We’re delighted to have this opportunity. All we’ll ask in return is for permission to use the results.’

  ‘Absolutely,’ West agreed. He’d be sure to tell Morrison; it might go some way toward making up for the car. ‘I’ll organise to have the child’s skull sent over to you in the next few days.’

  ‘No need for that,’ the professor said, surprising him, ‘all we need are a series of photographs and accurate dimensions of the various bones. I’ll liaise directly with Fiona; she knows what I need.’

  It was as simple as that.

  Then it was just a matter of waiting. The professor had given no indication of time frame apart from his muttering about having to change parameters. West thought it wiser not to ask.